Social media is pulsating at the news of Q host Jian Ghomeshi being fired from the CBC. I will withhold judgement on private sexual acts without having hard facts from either side. Where I do deserve to have an opinion is on the criticism of three women who chose not to report these crimes to the police.
Kevin Donovan of the Toronto Star writes in his October 26th article that “None of the women has contacted police. When asked why by the Star, the women cited several reasons including fears that a police report would expose their names and worries that their consent or acceptance of fantasy role-play discussions in text or other messages with Ghomeshi would be used against them as evidence of consent to actual violence.”
Back off internet. It’s complicated and women who are ‘good girls’ by ‘doing the right thing’ in calling 911 after a sexual assault often become victimized over and over again. Like I was.
I was the victim of a break-and-enter and violent sexual assault in Toronto on February 1, 1997. I didn’t know him, but strangely he had lived in all of the same cities and had attended the same universities as I had. Freaky. That night he finished doing what he intended, and told me to not move until I heard him leave through my front door. I complied and then lay there, not quite knowing what I should do. The first call I made was to my boyfriend at the time and he told me to dial 911. So I did. I had no idea the chain of events that would ensue and last until 2008.
The national Canadian DNA Databank came into effect in June of 2000 and there was quite a backlog of samples to cross reference into the system. I was departing on a romantic trip to Europe in 2002 when I got the call from Toronto Police Services. Did I know a man by the name of X? No. I began to shake just like I am trembling now as I write this article. The police had matched his DNA to samples taken from the crime scene of my assault. I was to go to the station to look at photos. He was in custody and I remember calling the officer in charge from phone booths all over Paris and Rome each time he had a court appearance. What if he was released? How did he know me? Was I stalked? Why did he do this? I wanted to ask him all of these questions but nobody would let me.
The trial began in 2003, and the actual sexual assault was nowhere near as bad as what I endured in court. What I realized is that you call 911 and go to trial for the good of society – not for yourself. Years later it was hard to recall the aftermath of the morning of Feb.1, 1997. This made everything more difficult. Thankfully, I didn’t have alcohol in my bloodstream when they tested me after the assault. Thankfully, my outfit from the night before was conservative (yes I was asked). Thankfully, I couldn’t even identify him in photos and refused to perjur myself in the courtroom by assuming the man who stared at me was the actual guy who did this. I could only trust the DNA.
Questions like what I wore to the police station the next morning and why I didn’t return to the hospital a week later to have my bruises photographed (they didn’t appear right away) stumped me 6 years later. And then there was the jury. I’d said I took a streetcar up Bathurst Street to get back to my apartment in the Annex on the night of the crime. One juror, a life-long Torontonian, decided that I must be lying about everything because Bathurst St. has busses and not streetcars at that time of night. She wrote to the judge and we narrowly avoided a mistrial. I was on the stand for two straight days, and was proud of my strength and wit. They tried to spin it that I had picked up this man in a bar in order to make my boyfriend jealous. The police questioned the boyfriend days after the assault and he left the station with doubts about my innocence. Between my PTSD and the seeds planted in his head, we drifted apart soon after.
The trial was surreal. On one side of the courtroom sat my friends and family – even Jane Doe came to support me. Like a twisted wedding, his family sat on the other side and they scowled at me for making them pay a defence lawyer. I avoided his eye contact as much as I could. Christie Blatchford wrote a beautiful article in the Globe and Mail about our two families watching and the piercing level of emotion and sadness in the room.
I had been an actor training at the University of Toronto in 1997, and found that I couldn’t be in the public eye after the assualt, so I graduated early and left school. Later as an employee at Hart House I was in charge of producing theatre and music, which allowed me to be close to my passions without fear that I might be stalked. I did agree to go on stage once during my tenure for the opening of the Isabel Bader Theatre. Unfortunately while being cross-examined I explained that I left my future career in the theatre after being assaulted and ‘hadn’t been on stage since’. While the sentiment was correct in terms of no longer making a living as an actor, the defence found a photo of me ‘on stage’ and called perjury. I had already flown to Toronto twice for the trial and now the judge wanted to meet with me again. I hired a lawyer, met with the judge virtually and was cleared of any lies or misunderstandings. But I’m sure I got a few premature grey hairs during the process.
The jury convicted him and the judge sentenced him to six years in prison, which is one of the harshest sentences handed down for a crime like this in Canada. He was placed in the Don Valley jail for some of it and 3 days for every 1 spent there were taken off his sentence – because the jail was in disrepair. So he got out after a couple of years, and I would get calls and letters from the parole board every time he travelled to Vancouver. I wasn’t allowed to know what he did for a living or where he resided (to protect his privacy). I didn’t leave my house much when I knew he was in town, and still when I travel to Toronto I look around skittishly just in case.
If you’re ever going to get assaulted, my case was pretty perfect: DNA evidence, no alcohol, no slutty clothes, a guy I didn’t know, and no history of kinky sex. Yes, they asked that too.
So in the Jian Ghomeshi case? A celebrity? BDSM? CBC, our national pride and joy? Frankly I’m with the women who didn’t call the police.
If it all happened to me again I would only call 911 knowing that I’m sacrificing myself for the the potential of a safer society.
Oh Jill…I had no idea! Your story is brave, chilling and very enlightening. Thank you for sharing this. Your voice is so important.
Thanks sweetie. Not sure how brave but way stronger now that it’s all done!
No, insanely brave. Make no mistake.
You are a brave woman…so brave. And I’m so sorry you went through that. I had no idea. I do now and I respect you and honour you. xo
Thanks Michelle. It’s one of those stories that you assume everyone just knows! Huge hugs. xo
OMG Jill, thank you for sharing your story and rehashing this horror all over again (both of them). Wow… Everyone who asks “why didn’t she…” needs to read your story.
Sharing the stories of our past is so valuable jill. Sending you a squeeze.
Thank you Jill, for being so brave and sharing your story – I am sure hearing about your journey will help others – but more importantly I hope it helps you heal. To know that you are an innocent victim being mistreated in our judicial system is simply inexcusable. What happened to you is inexcusable compounded by vitriolic lawyers. Stand strong, chin up and thank you for being strong enough to share your story.
Oh Jill, I’m so sorry this happened to you. You are so brave to write this. Wow. xo
Love you to the moon and back Jill. I’m so proud of you for sharing your story. Sending you so much love! xoxoxo
Thank you.
I am a feminist I understand that women find it difficult to go to the police, but to go to the employer??? To me it smells of revenge. Time will tell. And CBC is playing police without giving him a fair trial. Gosh, policemen are given time off with pay pending an investigation.
… One of the complainants was an employee of the CBC who Ghomeshi said he wanted to “hate fuck”, and from what I understand, there was more than one incidence of workplace harassment, and that one incident alone is grounds for dismissal.
“To me it smells of revenge”. Why is it relevant that you are a feminist? Do you believe that lends to your credibility? I am a feminist too and that has nothing to do with this commentary. The consequence under the law for breaking the law, is punishment, which can be said to equal revenge. Justice is something else altogether. Justice empowers the victim. Think about that while you judge the intentions of these women.
XO
You were at the trial every day! XO back!!!!
Having also been through a sexual assault trial I had the same reaction that you did to the cries of “why didn’t they go to the police!?!”
I am thankful that those making the statements have clearly never had to endure the unfairness and indignity that is testifying about being sexually assaulted. Perhaps now is a good time to get out this part of the story.
I am sorry for what you went through. I wouldn’t wish it on anyone. The assault itself, or the resulting trial.
Thank you so much for sharing Jennifer. It’s pretty awful and you are right about indignity. Getting to the other side of all thankfully makes the dignity stronger. xo
Thank you for your bravery and for sharing your story. I am sorry this happened to you.
Brave and thoughtful article. Thanks for sharing this difficult story, and, for playing a part in this man’s conviction. Best wishes, Mary
I really admire your courage and bravery in sharing your story so publicly. Thank you for giving us a very important perspective.
Thank you so much for speaking out, I admire the courage that took. I’m also very sorry that you had to endure all of that.
Thank you Janice. The courage took a while to come!!!
Oh Jill, my gd my heart just sank when I saw you were the author. I feel ashamed of myself for just recently posting a comment on another friends wall questioning why these women didn’t go to the police if they were assaulted. Thank you for sharing your story, I am so incredibly sorry that you had to endure this but I think all women need to read your post. You are so brave and so strong. xo
Oh Kathryn, thank you and that’s why I shared. It’s a really though decision for any woman and so many people have reached out to me today with stories of heroism and regret for reporting or not reporting. I only wish we didn’t have to talk about the issue at all. xo
You hit that out of the ballpark. I’m VERY grateful that you had the guts to share your story candidly. Thank you for sharing a story that has become unspeakable for too many other women.
Oh Louise, thank you. I wasn’t planning on sharing, but it just all came out when I heard people criticize potential victims. Too much.
I am so sorry that you had to endure all of this. Thank you for sharing your post. It was very brave of you to do so.
You are so brave, both for sharing this story and for reporting the crime for the good of society. Hugs.
Dear Jill,
Reading your recent post made my blood boil with anger at the guy who did that horrible act to you. I am so very sad to hear that he, and the legal system, put you through such hell.
You are such a brave woman in so many different ways. Huge respect and love, xoxo
Jill, thank you so much for sharing this story. I cannot begin to imagine what an ordeal it is for someone to go through an assault and trial and see it through to the end. You’re incredibly brave to share this and help answer the “why didn’t she report it” questions we have been hearing these past couple of days.
You are a strong and wise young woman. While I will NEVER forget the trauma of all this.,I am so proud of you for continuing to stand up for the many victims. Also, Thankyou for your dear family and friends whose constant support gave you the. Courage to continue. Gungabear.xo
Dear Jill,
Thank you for your courage, bravery and love in sharing this piece. I went through something similar eight years after you, in Toronto. There were strange and painful moments all the way through with 911, the police, the courts, insurance, my employer, and even my family. I perceive in your story that the pain and grief have become part of your strength. I feel that for myself, and each time the grief comes up again, I know it clears the way for joy as well. The Marge Piercy poem: ‘For strong women’ http://www.dragonflydream.com/Strong.html.
First I’m sorry you had to go thru this… But. As I start a What an amazing piece of writing – thank you for sharing.
I was a victim of attempted rape at the age of 21. I fought with my known attacker and got away. I did not report it. I did not tell anyone for almost 2 years. Mainly it was because I was pretty messed up about it. I blamed myself, felt embarrassed and ashamed for putting myself in that position (how could I have known?). I knew my family wouldn’t be able to support me emotionally if I went to police and I couldn’t have handled being blamed by them or the police for something that I neither invited nor encouraged. Plus, I would’ve had to face him. And all of our friends would know.
In the case of Jian, we don’t know that a crime happened yet. If it did and they didn’t report it, I totally get it. If it didn’t and they are just ramping up charges against him I hope they are punished. This will mar him, whether he’s innocent or not. I think that there is a difference between consenting and later repealing and saying that you really didn’t say yes, and saying no in the moment or at any point during the act. Rape culture is alive and well in Canada. So what are we going to do about it?
such a brave and thoughtful thing for you to do given that it is probably opening old wounds. thank you for writing it
Beautifully written. I’m so very sorry you experienced this – but am so proud to know you. Thank you for sharing your story. Sending you all kinds of love. xoxo
Thanks Danielle! Means the world from you. Just did a radio interview and I am going to crawl under a rock now!!!! xoxo
I’ve heard similar stories on how hard it is to go to court and be accused – it would be hard for anyone to admit that happened. Thanks so much for sharing that!
I don’t know what to beleive in the Jian Gomeshi story but I do know that women are not fairly defended in our Canadian court system. My sister was assaulted at a very young age, took the stand with our parent’s support and was demoralized, victimized and left realling from this terrible experience. He got off, his employer lying for himr. My sister and parents had to live with his lie. I’m not sure if I would call 911 if I was a victim.
I see lots of sisters here for you which is great to see but the lack of support or comments from men (so far) is…I was going to say shocking, but really it’s not, is it? It’s kind of pathetic. What you went through no one should ever go through, yet on it goes. I have no idea what makes certain men do what they do. Of all the ‘wrong’ things in the world, this is pretty much at the top of the filthy heap. I also admire your courage and thank you for writing this piece and getting it ‘out there.’
If I could have one wish for my own sons, it is that they should have the courage of women. Adrienne Rich
Jill, this is a very eye-opening, disturbing essay. Thank you for sharing these painful memories. I think it will help to educate people. You haven’t finished making sacrifices for the good of society, obviously. (Note typo in previous post.)
Thanks Kurtis! Deleted the typo and published this one. xx
Love you Jill, thanks for sharing your powerful story.
What a heroeing life event, I can’t even imagine! You are a very brave person! As a complete stranger (and female), thank you for your strength and your courage to relive and bring awareness to people. Society is so messed up, but with good honest people, like yourself, you make it better. You should write a book of your life experience! Much love and well wishes to you!
Wow Jenny – thank you so much!!!
I, too, appreciate your forthright and brave admission. Only those who have experienced what you did are qualified to make the statements you did and I thank you.
P.S. Could you please ask your Web manager to ensure the ads are fixed so that they don’t cover the end bits of every line? Just sayin’.
Thanks.
Claire – thank you so much! Our webmaster is looking at it – would you mind letting me know what browser you’re using and if you’re on a Mac, PC or tablet? Thank you!!
I’m on a tablet and I can only read bits of your story. BTW, I rarely publicly comment, but you are worth it. You’re amazing! Thank you for sharing!
Oh Simone – thank you!!!!!!
Jill, I want to thank you for this beautiful article.
I was molested in the middle of the night, at a sleep over party at a friend’s house, when I was 18. It woke me up. I still remember the fear. I didn’t scream. I didn’t even move. It was as if every energy was sucked out of me. I was stunned, because I thought he was my friend. I trusted him. It felt as if my muscles froze, like I was paralyzed. All I could do was close my eyes, pretend to be asleep, and pray that he stops. And I never told any one, because I was certain that no one would believe me. “Oh you must be dreaming” “Why were you sleeping right next to him?” “Why didn’t you tell him to stop?” I was afraid people would ask me those questions and I will not be able to give perfect answers. I felt ashamed (even though it was not my fault), stupid (because I slept, at a sleep over) and didn’t want to tell my friends or family. I didn’t want people to look at me differently, or to call me a slut.
So, thank you, for writing this article. I hope more people can understand what it is like to be a victim, and to be victimized all over again in the public eyes.
Jill, I just heard your moving interview on CBCs The Current. Thank you for adding your voice and experience to what’s being discussed in Canada. I’m sorry about what happened to you, so sorry. You are truly a brave woman.
Doug
Dear Jill,
Just moments ago, I heard your interview with Annamaria on CBC radio…… What a horrifying experience for you and so courageous to share it.
I am a retired junior high teacher and for certain, I would use your story in my classes…
The developments this past couple of weeks with Jian, I suspect, has given many girls and women a stronger sense of who we are and that we can tell our stories…
Bless you … you are successful today and am so proud of you! Jan
Jill I heard the interview with Anna Maria Tremonti this morning. I sat in my car in a parking lot until it was finished and it brought me to tears.
I can’t tell you how much I admire your courage and your commitment to other women. I was also struck by the positive nature of your comments about the justice system – that has got to be a helpful message across the country.
This is an important addition to the discussion about women don’t report assault …because reporting it often leads to revictimization and continued victimization and often prevents women from getting on with their lives. Thanks for writing this.
Dear Jill – than you for your piece above and for your, frankly, brave interview on the CBC. The attack you endured and the subsequent systemic treatment by the legal system made me feel angry and sad. I am sure you know how much your bravery helps the voiceless thousands who choose not to report the crimes committed against them out of fear of being re-victimised.
On a brighter note, congratulations with your company and the impact you are having through your business! I hope you are doing well.
Andrew, that means the world coming from you. Thank you. I really do believe things are changing, and though I never expected to share in such a big way, I’m glad I did. I love your updates from across the pond – I will let you know when I am next there!!
[…] many readers know, I had to testify at a pretty nasty criminal trial and marvelled at the grey areas between truth and lies. There were always many […]
[…] you did not hear about my own trial experience as a sexual assault victim, I was quite outspoken about the victimization of victims when Ghomeshi was […]
[…] not hear about my own trial experience as a sexual assault victim, I was quite outspoken about the victimization of victims when Ghomeshi was […]
Thank you for being so open and vulnerable in sharing your experience here. I feel like many people overlook the challenges faced by the victim when they make accusations that people are making false claims or questioning the decisions that they made leading up to what happened. It’s time that we take a step back and look at the flawed system. The idea that the victims of crimes like this are further victimized is a clear indication that there is MUCH room for improvement!
It was really use full and help us information about the thoughts on victimization and jinni Ghomeshi thanks sharing this article